Establish Evaluation Criteria

The evaluation criteria provide the basis for evaluating alternative solutions. The criteria are ranked so that the highest ranked criteria exert the most influence on the evaluation. [PA156.IG101.SP103.N101] This process area is referenced by many other process areas in the model, and there are many contexts in which a formal evaluation process can be used. Therefore, in some situatio

Document the evaluation criteria to minimize the possibility that decisions will be second-guessed, or that the reason for making the decision will be forgotten. Decisions based on criteria that are explicitly defined and established remove barriers to stakeholder buy-in.

• Define the criteria for evaluating alternative solutions. Criteria should be traceable to requirements, scenarios, business case assumptions, business objectives, or other documented sources. Types of criteria to consider include:
  • Technology limitations
  • Environmental impact
  • Risks
  • Total ownership and life-cycle costs
• Define the range and scale for ranking the evaluation criteria. Scales of relative importance for evaluation criteria can be established with nonnumeric values or with formulas that relate the evaluation parameter to a numerical weight.
• Rank the criteria. The criteria are ranked according to the defined range and scale to reflect the needs, objectives, and priorities of the relevant stakeholders.
• Assess the criteria and their relative importance.
• Evolve the evaluation criteria to improve their validity.
• Document the rationale for the selection and rejection of evaluation criteria. Documentation of selection criteria and rationale may be needed to justify solutions or for future reference and use.